Ready to increase your revenue?
Join thousands of ecommerce brands using PostPilot to acquire more customers & keep them coming back again (and again).
No contracts. No minimums.

If you’re at a pet brand, you have a golden opportunity to drive more new- and repeat revenue. And it rhymes with “shmirect shmail.”
That was not one of our better openings, but you’re here, and that’s great, because you’re about to see how direct mail can bring owners (and their pets) back to you for more and more… and more.
Basically, it comes down to the fact that direct mail can easily add automated physical touchpoints to all your existing owned digital strategies.
(Plus prospecting, to diversify from Meta and co.)
And that should make you sigh with relief and bark with joy, because in the face of lower open rates and packed inboxes (and all the other delights you fight on a daily basis), you’ll actually be able to get your offers seen with mail.
So, let’s talk about that.
Pet brands have one big advantage over most of DTC: your customers have to buy again. The dog eats twice a day whether or not anyone opens your emails.
So you already know they'll reorder. What you can't control is where they do it, or whether they think of you first.
Luckily, pet brands get a whole calendar of built-in reasons to show up: the bag running low, the autoship that just got canceled, the birthday, the gotcha day. Every one of those is a date or an event already sitting in Shopify, Klaviyo, or your subscription app.
Direct mail can fire off all of those triggers. And when it does, the card lands on the kitchen counter next to the treat jar and stays there for days, where everyone in the house sees it (including whoever's in charge of ordering the food).
Mail works at the top of the funnel, too. If most of your new-customer budget runs through Meta and co., direct mail prospecting gives you a second acquisition channel to lean on.
If we may quote Tim Mitchum, president and CEO of WINPRO Pet:
We've laid these out in the order a customer experiences your brand: first impression, first order, first reorder, subscription, birthdays, and the occasional disappearing act.
You don't have to build all six at once.
(Generally, we recommend starting with retention and retargeting. But we'll go in this order for narrative reasons.)
Anyone who's switched a dog's food knows it's a whole thing (the slow transition, the upset stomach, the side-eye from the dog).
So once owners find something that works, they tend to stick with it, which means you want to be the brand they find first.
AcquisitionAI, PostPilot's lookalike engine, is built for exactly this.
It learns from your best customers, then puts a card in front of net-new households that look like them. You set a budget and a cadence (daily, weekly, or monthly), and the cards go out on their own.
For a pet brand, VIP (very important pets) are the ones the model would build off and learning from.
In terms of postcard creative, we recommend keeping it simple, and leading with your hero (likely what you're doing in many of your best ads).
Pet parents do their homework, especially on anything their dog eats or sleeps on. Plenty of them add something to cart and wander off to "think about it."
Barker Beds, the science-backed dog bed brand, sends a postcard to never-buyers who abandoned a cart five days earlier, and those cards run at 10x+ ROAS.
MailMatch™ identifies their home addresses from email information alone, so the card can reach shoppers who left before giving one.

Here's how Amanda Friemann, Campaign Manager at Barker Beds, puts it: "MailMatch™ [has] been instrumental in helping us reconnect with dog parents who showed interest but didn't convert. [It gives] us a second chance to reintroduce our story and build trust, especially with customers who need a little more time or information to decide."
Your customers run out of food on a schedule, and you have the order data to know roughly when. That's a replenishment campaign waiting to happen, and it's the play pet brands are most built for.
Start by pulling time-between-orders by product and size, because a 4-lb bag of treats and a 30-lb bag of kibble run out on very different clocks. Then trigger a card off the Shopify order, timed a bit earlier than your email reminder (the card has to travel, after all).
A couple of creative rules to keep in mind:
Bonus points if the card doubles as an autoship pitch. Someone who ran low once is going to run low again, and "never run out" is an easy sell to a person staring at an empty scoop.
Your autoship customers are your best customers, which is exactly why churn stings so much.
Good news: Recharge sends subscription-canceled events to PostPilot, so a card can go out as soon as someone cancels. The trick is what that card says, and the best answer we've seen is to match it to why they left.
Here's how that maps for a pet brand:
And for subscribers who canceled a while ago, a card about new or improved formulas gives them a fresh reason to restart.
Most brands get one birthday per customer. You get up to three: the owner's, the pet's, and, for rescues, the gotcha day (the anniversary of the adoption).
Birthday cards are already some of the strongest retention sends we see, and most brands only get to send them to people.
A card addressed to the dog is going straight on the fridge. (Also, nobody in the house is touchy about the dog's age.)
Here's the setup:
Keep the offer small and sweet. A free treat with the next order fits the occasion way better than a sitewide discount. And for your VIPs, send it as a handwritten card.
Every brand has customers who go quiet. The upside for pet brands is that you can usually tell when someone's gone quiet, because you know how long a bag lasts.
A calendar window is a fine place to start. WINPRO Pet, which makes supplement soft chews for dogs, runs an automated VIP winback to customers with three or more orders and no purchase in 120 days, and it's cleared 15x+ ROAS.
"These are VIP customers, and we're constantly able to reach out and get ahold of them, to bring them back," Mitchum said.
From there, you can tighten the window by product. Someone who's two bags overdue on food has lapsed, whatever the calendar says.
WINPRO has another move we love, which Mitchum calls post-offers.

After a Memorial Day email offer, the brand sent the same 20% discount by mail to customers who didn't open the email. That card scored 8x ROAS.
And then there are the customers who've unsubscribed. Once someone opts out of email and SMS, those channels can't reach them at all... but a postcard still can, because their address is already in your order history.
Five of these six plays run on a trigger your stack already has: an order, a cancellation, a date, a lapse. (Prospecting runs on a budget and a cadence you set once.) Build each one, and it keeps firing every time a pet parent hits that moment, just like your email flows do.
We connect to Shopify, Klaviyo, and Recharge, so the cards fire off the same events your emails already use. We're also a Klaviyo Premier Tech Partner (Klaviyo's highest partner designation), and you can build your Klaviyo segments right inside PostPilot instead of starting from scratch.
The dog's going to keep eating either way. Might as well be your food.
Ready to put direct mail to work from first impression to fifth birthday?
If you’re at a pet brand, you have a golden opportunity to drive more new- and repeat revenue. And it rhymes with “shmirect shmail.”
That was not one of our better openings, but you’re here, and that’s great, because you’re about to see how direct mail can bring owners (and their pets) back to you for more and more… and more.
Basically, it comes down to the fact that direct mail can easily add automated physical touchpoints to all your existing owned digital strategies.
(Plus prospecting, to diversify from Meta and co.)
And that should make you sigh with relief and bark with joy, because in the face of lower open rates and packed inboxes (and all the other delights you fight on a daily basis), you’ll actually be able to get your offers seen with mail.
So, let’s talk about that.
Pet brands have one big advantage over most of DTC: your customers have to buy again. The dog eats twice a day whether or not anyone opens your emails.
So you already know they'll reorder. What you can't control is where they do it, or whether they think of you first.
Luckily, pet brands get a whole calendar of built-in reasons to show up: the bag running low, the autoship that just got canceled, the birthday, the gotcha day. Every one of those is a date or an event already sitting in Shopify, Klaviyo, or your subscription app.
Direct mail can fire off all of those triggers. And when it does, the card lands on the kitchen counter next to the treat jar and stays there for days, where everyone in the house sees it (including whoever's in charge of ordering the food).
Mail works at the top of the funnel, too. If most of your new-customer budget runs through Meta and co., direct mail prospecting gives you a second acquisition channel to lean on.
If we may quote Tim Mitchum, president and CEO of WINPRO Pet:
We've laid these out in the order a customer experiences your brand: first impression, first order, first reorder, subscription, birthdays, and the occasional disappearing act.
You don't have to build all six at once.
(Generally, we recommend starting with retention and retargeting. But we'll go in this order for narrative reasons.)
Anyone who's switched a dog's food knows it's a whole thing (the slow transition, the upset stomach, the side-eye from the dog).
So once owners find something that works, they tend to stick with it, which means you want to be the brand they find first.
AcquisitionAI, PostPilot's lookalike engine, is built for exactly this.
It learns from your best customers, then puts a card in front of net-new households that look like them. You set a budget and a cadence (daily, weekly, or monthly), and the cards go out on their own.
For a pet brand, VIP (very important pets) are the ones the model would build off and learning from.
In terms of postcard creative, we recommend keeping it simple, and leading with your hero (likely what you're doing in many of your best ads).
Pet parents do their homework, especially on anything their dog eats or sleeps on. Plenty of them add something to cart and wander off to "think about it."
Barker Beds, the science-backed dog bed brand, sends a postcard to never-buyers who abandoned a cart five days earlier, and those cards run at 10x+ ROAS.
MailMatch™ identifies their home addresses from email information alone, so the card can reach shoppers who left before giving one.

Here's how Amanda Friemann, Campaign Manager at Barker Beds, puts it: "MailMatch™ [has] been instrumental in helping us reconnect with dog parents who showed interest but didn't convert. [It gives] us a second chance to reintroduce our story and build trust, especially with customers who need a little more time or information to decide."
Your customers run out of food on a schedule, and you have the order data to know roughly when. That's a replenishment campaign waiting to happen, and it's the play pet brands are most built for.
Start by pulling time-between-orders by product and size, because a 4-lb bag of treats and a 30-lb bag of kibble run out on very different clocks. Then trigger a card off the Shopify order, timed a bit earlier than your email reminder (the card has to travel, after all).
A couple of creative rules to keep in mind:
Bonus points if the card doubles as an autoship pitch. Someone who ran low once is going to run low again, and "never run out" is an easy sell to a person staring at an empty scoop.
Your autoship customers are your best customers, which is exactly why churn stings so much.
Good news: Recharge sends subscription-canceled events to PostPilot, so a card can go out as soon as someone cancels. The trick is what that card says, and the best answer we've seen is to match it to why they left.
Here's how that maps for a pet brand:
And for subscribers who canceled a while ago, a card about new or improved formulas gives them a fresh reason to restart.
Most brands get one birthday per customer. You get up to three: the owner's, the pet's, and, for rescues, the gotcha day (the anniversary of the adoption).
Birthday cards are already some of the strongest retention sends we see, and most brands only get to send them to people.
A card addressed to the dog is going straight on the fridge. (Also, nobody in the house is touchy about the dog's age.)
Here's the setup:
Keep the offer small and sweet. A free treat with the next order fits the occasion way better than a sitewide discount. And for your VIPs, send it as a handwritten card.
Every brand has customers who go quiet. The upside for pet brands is that you can usually tell when someone's gone quiet, because you know how long a bag lasts.
A calendar window is a fine place to start. WINPRO Pet, which makes supplement soft chews for dogs, runs an automated VIP winback to customers with three or more orders and no purchase in 120 days, and it's cleared 15x+ ROAS.
"These are VIP customers, and we're constantly able to reach out and get ahold of them, to bring them back," Mitchum said.
From there, you can tighten the window by product. Someone who's two bags overdue on food has lapsed, whatever the calendar says.
WINPRO has another move we love, which Mitchum calls post-offers.

After a Memorial Day email offer, the brand sent the same 20% discount by mail to customers who didn't open the email. That card scored 8x ROAS.
And then there are the customers who've unsubscribed. Once someone opts out of email and SMS, those channels can't reach them at all... but a postcard still can, because their address is already in your order history.
Five of these six plays run on a trigger your stack already has: an order, a cancellation, a date, a lapse. (Prospecting runs on a budget and a cadence you set once.) Build each one, and it keeps firing every time a pet parent hits that moment, just like your email flows do.
We connect to Shopify, Klaviyo, and Recharge, so the cards fire off the same events your emails already use. We're also a Klaviyo Premier Tech Partner (Klaviyo's highest partner designation), and you can build your Klaviyo segments right inside PostPilot instead of starting from scratch.
The dog's going to keep eating either way. Might as well be your food.
Ready to put direct mail to work from first impression to fifth birthday?
Join thousands of ecommerce brands using PostPilot to acquire more customers & keep them coming back again (and again).
No contracts. No minimums.
